Research Argument
Develop a sustained research argument with claims, evidence, citations, counterargument, and implications.
A lesson of English 12, in Senior Research and Inquiry, about 10 minutes.
By the end of this lesson, you will be able to write a complete, college-level research argument that integrates your literature review, advances an original thesis, and meets academic standards for evidence and citation.
The Research Argument Paper
A research argument is more than a research paper — it makes an original contribution to a scholarly conversation. Unlike a research report (which summarizes what others have said), the research argument advances your own thesis while engaging substantively with existing scholarship.
The key characteristics:
- A specific, arguable thesis that could be published in an academic journal
- A literature review that positions the argument
- Evidence from primary and secondary sources
- A clear line of reasoning
- Engagement with counterarguments from the scholarship
- Proper citation throughout
Structure
Abstract (if required): 150-250 words summarizing the research question, methodology, argument, and significance.
Introduction:
- Hook/problem
- Literature review (concise — who has said what; where is the gap?)
- Thesis
Body:
- Organized by your argument, not your sources
- Each section advances one major claim
- Primary evidence + secondary support + your analysis
Counterargument:
- From existing scholarship (not just strawmen)
- Genuinely engaged with and responded to
Conclusion:
- Restate thesis in light of what you've shown
- Significance: what does this contribute?
- Limitations: what can't this claim address?
- Future directions: what questions remain?
Works Cited / References: every source cited; formatted correctly.
The Introduction at College Level
The college-level introduction to a research paper does something the high school introduction does not: it positions the argument within a scholarly conversation.
Elements:
- The problem or question that motivates the research
- Brief synthesis of existing approaches (where are scholars right now?)
- The gap the project addresses
- The specific thesis
This is typically 3-5 paragraphs in a longer research paper.