Trade Barriers and Trade Policy
Evaluate tariffs, quotas, subsidies, trade agreements, protectionism, and their effects on consumers, producers, and governments.
A lesson of Economics, in Global Economics, about 10 minutes.
By the end of this lesson, you will be able to describe the types of trade barriers, evaluate the arguments for protectionism and free trade, and explain how trade agreements reduce barriers.
Why Countries Restrict Trade
Despite the economic case for free trade (gains from comparative advantage), governments routinely restrict imports. Why?
Political economy: the losers from trade (domestic producers who compete with imports) are concentrated, organized, and politically active. The winners (consumers who pay lower prices) are diffuse and often unaware of the gains.
Infant industry argument: new domestic industries may need temporary protection until they can compete globally.
National security: some industries (defense, critical infrastructure) should not be offshored.
Retaliation: if a trading partner restricts your exports, you may restrict theirs.
Types of Trade Barriers
Tariff: a tax on imported goods. Raises the price of imported goods → consumers pay more → domestic producers are protected.
Who pays? Primarily domestic consumers and businesses that use imported inputs. (Despite political claims, foreign exporters do not pay tariffs — the price falls on whoever buys the imported good domestically.)
Import quota: a limit on the quantity of a good that can be imported. Creates a shortage at the existing price → domestic price rises. Protects domestic producers; hurts consumers. Unlike a tariff, generates no government revenue (the windfall goes to whoever holds the import licenses).
Voluntary export restraints (VERs): an agreement by a foreign country to voluntarily limit its exports. Example: Japan's auto VERs with the US in the 1980s.
Non-tariff barriers: regulations, standards, customs delays, licensing requirements that effectively restrict imports without being explicit trade barriers.
Subsidies to domestic producers: make domestic firms more competitive against imports without taxing imports directly.
Effects of a Tariff (Graphical)
A tariff on imported cars:
- Raises the domestic price of cars
- Domestic producers supply more (gaining producer surplus)
- Consumers buy fewer cars (losing consumer surplus)
- Government collects tariff revenue
- Net result: deadweight loss (the consumer loss exceeds the producer gain + government revenue)
Arguments for Protectionism
| Argument | Validity |
|---|